Post by &JORGE! on Apr 19, 2008 12:48:25 GMT -5
So, i posted a post on RPGC for one of the members to critique on the site, and so far, the feedback is fairly pretty good!
Plot -7
Comments: It seems almost like an advertisement. I like the overall idea but it doesn't seem like a huge plot. If you like it like that keep it that way. It caught my attention though and I like it.
Compliments: see comments
Advice: see comments
Rules -8
Comments: They are good. I feel as though the covered everything, there may be a few things missing but I can't think of any. They are sort of long and take a while to read, I know that may be necessary but it may turn some people away.
Compliments: see comments.
Advice: see comments.
Boards -9
Comments: I love them. I feel as though the name tells it all and the descriptions are good. The only thing is the descriptions are small and long meaning that most people would only read them if they have to, though that might not be a bad thing.
Compliments: see comments.
Advice: see comments.
Spelling & Grammar -10
Comments: I didn't do a super check but from what I read the spelling and grammar was great! Also, you mentioned it in your rules so good for you!
Compliments: see comments.
Advice: see comments.
Overall -9
Thoughts On The Site As A Whole: When I fist saw it I was impressed. The main screen look good and caught my attention, making me want to read more.
Overall Suggestions: This is very minor, but at the bottom where it says who everyone is and who is online looks a little strange.
Total Score -9
Comments & Suggestions
I think the site is great. Just looking and skimming over it I can see how much time was put into the site.
